In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human cloning. Publication date 20001008 topics cloning, islam, clonning effects, genom effects etc. Lacking direct revelation on human cloning in sacred texts, casuistical and analogical reasoning has been a characteristic part of religious argumentation. Sources and modus operandi abul fadl mohsin ebrahim, v the gendered discourse of the preparation for burial in premodern muslim societies hadas hirsch v investigation of articles in literature related to islam and bioethics in the example of american.
A thoughtprovoking scientific research 9 qazi mujahidul islam qasmi creation and cloning 16 dr. Dec 07, 2014 therefore, human does not create but manipulates and that is permissible in islam as long as it is done to benefit allahs creation. Cloning in the quran and tradition islamic perspectives on human cloning. Lineage in the islamic law is one of the most basic human rights each individual inherits from his family. Cloning is the process of generating a genetically identical copy of a cell or an organism. Therefore, human does not create but manipulates and that is permissible in islam as. A team at newcastle university announced few days ago that it had successfully generated admixed embryos by adding human dna to empty cow eggs in the first experiment of its kind in britain.
Some callers alleged that cloning was a conspiracy through which developed nations were trying to take control of less developed nations and deform humanity. Many people of various faiths are offended by the concept of cloning. The dilemma with therapeutic cloning is that it requires stem cells and the best stem cells are those that are derived from early human embryos. Cloning in the quran and tradition islamic perspectives on. But cloning creates life from life and is just an extension of routine in vitro fertilization procedures. Cloning from the point of view of shariah 39 hazrat ml.
Religions reveal little consensus on cloning health. Perspectives on human cloning are theoretical, as human. Cloning in the light of shari qazi mujahidul islam qasmi by. This is the case with the issue of cloning in islam, despite the presence of several critical researches that have touched upon this topic eich 2006, 291 309. Karena belakangan ini telah berkembang satu teknologi baru yang mampu memduplikasi makhluk hidup dengan sama persis, teknologi ini dikenal dengan nama teknologi kloning. In the cloning process, the dna is removed from cells, manipulations of the dna are carried out in a testtube, and the dna is subsequently put back into cells. Christian ethics and cloning is fast becoming a topic that is difficult to ignore. The majority of scientists, bioethicists, religious scholars, policy makers, and international and national regulatory bodies favor a prohibition of reproductive cloning, but they differ over therapeutic cloning and stem cell research. Free download and read online cloning in the light of shari qazi mujahidul islam qasmi written by qazi mujahidul islam qasmi. Human cloning q is it permissible to create a human being using cloning if this scienti. Human actions, hence freedoms, are not absolute and are curtailed by law, public and individual conscience. A magazine of events and ideas london, 19841988, have played a pioneering role in creating an awareness about the social. While the bible does not specifically deal with the subject of human cloning, there are principles in scripture which may shed more light on the concept.
People have very different views of what is natural. Some people are demanding to ban cloning all together because it interferes with the process of creation. It is being debated internationally in various fora. Regarding cloning, there have been tremendous interest and anxiety expressed by the people. When it is looked at as a whole, the arguments against cloning human beings are much more convincing than those in favour. When modern assisted reproductive technologies appeared in recent decades, the issue of lineage and the childs rights did not encounter serious. Chapter three religious perspectives over the last twentyfive years religious thinkers have discussed the prospect of human cloning in the context of longstanding religious traditions that often influence and guide citizens responses to new technologies. Format of cloning in the light of shari qazi mujahidul islam qasmi is pdf and file size of this file is 732. But the religious authority sayyed muhammad hussein fadlullah. Indeed, human reproductive cloning profoundly challenges our deepest and most cherished beliefs and opens vast new arenas for scientific investigation. Nasser farid wasel, egypt s mufti, said in 1999 that cloning clearly contradicts islam. It is stated in the religion that anything which we cannot find a reason to prohibit is permissible without justification. In judaism, there are debates over whether cloning would be allowed.
Indiana university, bloomington, indiana, usa, his regular contributions in the monthly inquiry. Human cloning through the eyes of muslim scholars research. In biomedical research, cloning is broadly defined to mean the duplication of any kind of biological material for scientific study, such as a piece of dna or an individual cell. Qazi mujahidul islam qasmi cloning is a serious global issue today. At the center of the ethical debate about cloning in islam, as pointed out by alqaradawi and other muslim scholars, is the question of the ways in which cloning might affect familial relationships and responsibilities. Religious positions on human cloning are pluralistic in their premises. Cloning technology was invented during the twentieth century and now is poised to help define the twentyfirst. Religious traditions have gradually aspired to be informed communities of moral discourse on issues of reproductive and genetic technologies.
Human cloning in muslim ethics by ebrahim moosa mittees on the subject of cloning address two different a recent callin program on cloning on the popular qatarbased arabic television station aljazeera attracted a flood of irate calls. There are three main sources, which look as if cloning is permitted. Islam has no definitive position on the matter, but many muslim scholars are in support of therapeutic cloning, as it is their belief the soul enters at a later stage in fetal development. Ordinary human cloning, in which the nucleus of a living somatic cell from an individual is placed into the cytoplasm of an egg devoid of its nucleus, is not to be permitted. In the brave new world of cloning, most jewish ethicists and organizations are staking out the middle ground. When modern assisted reproductive technologies appeared in recent decades, the issue of lineage and the childs rights did not encounter serious challenges. In nature, many organisms produce clones through asexual reproduction. Human cloning in muslim ethics by ebrahim moosa mittees on the subject of cloning address two different a recent callin program on cloning on the popular.
Site uploaded this book under the category of islamic books pdf. In the islamic world, views on cloning tend to be subject to fine distinctions. Apr 15, 2020 cloning is the process of generating a genetically identical copy of a cell or an organism. In the wake of the february 1997 announcement that dolly the sheep had been cloned, muslim religious scholars together with. Some very serious ethical issues may arise in the human. A general consensus appears to be emerging in the jewish community that therapeutic cloningusing cloning technology for medical researchis acceptable, but reproductive cloningusing the technology to copy someoneis not.
Genetic engineering technologys focuses are into three major uses. Each day it seems there is more news from the scientific world of another milestone reached in cloning technology. Reactions to the operations of cloning varied, with many foreign countries issuing laws that prohibit these operations for all purposes whatsoever. In the light of better understanding of the facts regarding cloning, both through embryo. Hukum kloning dalam pandangan islam sangat jelas, yang diambil dari dalildalil qiyas dan itjihat. Cloning in the quran and tradition islamic perspectives. In order to understand these better, certain special properties of islamic law must be taken into consideration, as described in the following by the orientalist thomas eich. Muslim religious scholars on cloning useful technology or the work of the devil.
Development of a regional position on human cloning who emro. Jose cibelli and his colleagues made their first human clone on october th, 2001. A magazine of events and ideas london, 19841988, have played a pioneering role in creating an awareness about the social impact of reproductive technologies. Jul 28, 2015 free download and read online cloning in the light of shari qazi mujahidul islam qasmi written by qazi mujahidul islam qasmi. In recent years, genetic engineering has been used to modify and improve plants, animals and microorganisms to improve their value to fulfill human needs. Therefore, cloning becomes useful in the study of cell differentiation in biotechnology and medicine agnihotri, 2008. They added that this type of cloning proved to be successful only in skin tissues. In this paper, ethical aspects of modern biotechnology will be discussed from an islamic perspective to be followed by the khalifah on earth, accompanied with reallife examples of the benefits. It has a potential to give rise to a number of social problems if allowed to be put into practice. Cloning islamic perspective islamic supreme council of canada. In this paper, ethical aspects of modern biotechnology will be discussed from an islamic perspective to be followed by the khalifah on earth, accompanied with. Muslim, sikh jew or religion like islam christianity hinduism hinduism sikhism judaism or athiest peace constitution legal illegal punishment jokes. First, dna is removed from the nucleus of a creatures cell.
Reproductive cloning islamic views on creation of an. Cloning islamic perspective islamic supreme council of. So cloning for the purpose of enhancing the chances of procreating within a solid family structure will be regarded as an act of faith in the. A producing a living creature using cloning or similar techniques is permissible as these scienti. Cloning in the light of shari qazi mujahidul islam qasmi. Cloning is the process of producing genetically identical individuals of an organism either naturally or artificially. A member of a sect that believes life on earth was created by extraterrestrials claimed friday to have produced the worlds first human clone, a baby girl. But a clone would have exactly the same status that an identical twin already does. Islam seeks a balance between these three concentric circles. Definisi pengertian kloning kata kloning ini berasal dari kata clone kata dalam bahasa inggris yang berarti potongan yang digunakan untuk memperbanyak tanaman, kloning ini pertama kali muncul dari usulan herbert webber pada tahun 1903 dalam mengistilahkan sekelompok individu makhluk hidup yang dilahirkan dari satu induk tanpa proses seksual. The findings of this report help us understand religious opposition to cloning a little better, and the quotes from respondents can readily be transformed into new questionnaire items to assist future research studies that explore the topic more deeply. In this section, i wish to present some elements of the cultural context in which cloning was presented. The process of cloning may contradict this belief as cloning although the male and female gene is needed the clone can be made simply just using technology, without any sexual interaction.
While the world stretches its concepts of morality and ethics to encompass this new reality, the jewish world also endeavors to decide if human cloning is permitted. It is important to state from the outset that despite the plurality of reasoning and judicial formulations based on independent research and interpretation of normative legal sources in islamic tradition, there is a consensus on juridicalethical opinions among muslim religious experts on human cloning. The jurisprudent position regarding cloning and the discussion regarding the counterview is a writing by late ayatollah sayyed muhammad hussain fadlullah. There is no clear consensus yet in jewish law regarding cloning. They used eggs from female volunteers in the boston area. Further, cloning can be used as a research tool that can be useful in the scientific revolution especially in revolutionalizing study of cells. Feb 14, 2014 877why islam presents islam s perspective on cloning.
Lineage and the rights of cloned child in the islamic. Dolly the sheep had been cloned, muslim religious scholars together with muslim scientists held two conferences to discuss cloning from an islamic perspective. Feb 06, 2012 lineage in the islamic law is one of the most basic human rights each individual inherits from his family. In this section, i wish to present some elements of. Most, if not all islamic scholars have said that human cloning in islam is haram or prohibited for a number of reasons. Scholars are in the middle about this, but it seems like more people lean towards it being allowed. While many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well. Embryo cloning still depends on a human egg from a woman. Today, cloning presents us with our own new creation, a baby with no parents. Jewish and islamic thinkers have encouraged continuing laboratory research on animal and human cloning, while expressing deep moral reservations about transfer of a cloned human embryo to a womb for purposes of gestation and birth. The jurisprudent position regarding cloning ijtihad network. Human cloning in muslim ethics a by ebrahim moosa recent callin program on cloning on the popular qatarbased arabic television station aljazeera attracted a flood of irate calls.
Malcolm ritter, associated press, 122702 hollywood, fla. Animal cloning permissibility in islam is conditioned by no causing of harm to animals and the. In this article, the religious perspectives of islamic jurisprudence about this subject are discussed. In other words, although the religious order on human cloning can be an absolute permission based on the strong principle of permission, it is not unlikely that in. Cloning in biotechnology refers to the process of creating clones of organisms or copies of cells or dna fragments molecular cloning. Lineage and the rights of cloned child in the islamic jurisprudence. Dna cloning cloning is the process of moving a gene from the chromosome it occurs in naturally to an autonomously replicating vector. Dolly the sheep, the first cloned mammal, was born in. In islam, it is encouraged to find cures to diseases.
Majority argues that human cloning is not permitted. Almost everyone has heard of dolly, the cloned sheep born in 1996 but what about the. Aug 02, 2016 regarding cloning, there have been tremendous interest and anxiety expressed by the people. In their view, the embryo is certainly worthy of respect but not sacred until after implantation in the uterus. Islam and bioethics international conference programme v islamic medical ethics. Cloning aur islam naqi ahmed nadwi by naqi ahmed nadwi. If exceptional cases emerge in the future, they should be considered to verify compliance with the shariah islamic law. Islamic perspective on human cloning and stem cell research. Definisi dan pengertian kloning definisi dan pengertian. Muslims too are concerned about the recent developments in genetic engineering. So cloning for the purpose of enhancing the chances of procreating within a solid family structure will be regarded as an act of faith in the ultimate will of god as the giver of all life.
994 1070 1349 425 1472 1413 1621 346 322 254 1102 1387 947 655 1253 372 1155 376 635 114 45 105 1490 607 1065 261 343 928 1627 1178 354 1291 61 1346 946 416 81 745 1382 1174 813 490